our own marketplace is a platform where third-party sellers offer products alongside your own assortment, and the operator earns a commission on transactions rather than a retail margin on third-party sales. The difference between a marketplace and an online store is economic and operational rather than technological: the marketplace operator shifts from purchasing inventory to managing supply, product data quality and trust. This changes the business model, cost structure and legal obligations, which is why the decision to launch a marketplace belongs to the executive team rather than the e-commerce department.
Marketplace, dropshipping and online store: what sets these models apart?
Before making a technology decision, it is worth establishing which model you are actually considering. In practice, all three models often coexist within a single website.
Dropshipping is often an underrated intermediate step. It allows businesses to expand their assortment without holding inventory, while retaining full control over pricing and the brand. It also avoids triggering most of the legal obligations of a platform operator. For many businesses, dropshipping is the right first step, followed by a marketplace.
When a marketplace makes sense: six criteria
A marketplace pays off when the operator has something sellers lack and cannot obtain on their own. This is usually traffic, brand trust or access to a specific customer group. The following criteria have proved decisive in our projects.
- You have traffic that you are not monetising. Customers are looking for products you do not offer, and you can see this in your on-site search data and customer service enquiries. This is the strongest signal because a marketplace addresses demand that already exists.
- Expanding your assortment through direct purchasing is unprofitable. Complementary categories have low inventory turnover or high capital requirements, so you do not want to take on the inventory risk.
- You have a trust advantage in your category. Customers will buy another brand’s products from you because they trust your platform. Without this, the marketplace has no reason to exist.
- Supply is fragmented. There are numerous small suppliers without their own e-commerce capabilities, for whom your platform represents a viable sales channel rather than a competitor.
- You can offer sellers more than traffic. Logistics, financing, demand data and payment processing are examples. Traffic alone will attract sellers initially, but it will not retain them.
- You have the operational capacity to oversee quality. A marketplace without listing moderation and seller quality controls damages the operator’s brand faster than it generates commission revenue.
When a marketplace does not make sense
This section is more important than the previous one because a marketplace is easy to justify in a presentation and difficult to reverse once implemented.
- You do not have traffic. A marketplace monetises traffic rather than generating it. Without traffic, the empty-shelf problem becomes impossible to solve: sellers will not come without customers, and customers will not come without an assortment.
- Your own retail margin is higher than the commission you can realistically charge. If you sell products at a 40% margin, replacing them with third-party offers that generate a 10% commission is cannibalisation rather than growth.
- Your category requires full control over the customer experience. Products that require advice, configuration or installation are poorly suited to a model in which a third-party seller is responsible for customer service.
- You lack the resources to support sellers. Onboarding, settlements, disputes and content moderation require people, not just software, and typically call for a dedicated team from day one.
- You want to ‘test’ a marketplace on a small budget. A marketplace cannot operate below a certain minimum functional scope because missing components, such as settlements or moderation, undermine the entire model.
Marketplace economics: what drives profitability?
A commission-based model looks attractive until the operating costs are taken into account. The following structure is worth modelling using your own data before making a decision.
Typical commission rates in the enterprise market range from 8% to 15% of the transaction value, with operator EBITDA margins of around 7% to 9%. These figures come from Mirakl’s materials on the marketplace revenue model. They are platform vendor data rather than an independent benchmark, so we treat them as a starting point for building a financial model, not as targets.
The operator incurs the following costs:
- Seller acquisition and onboarding costs. Verification, contracts, catalogue integration and training. These are one-off costs, but they are not insignificant.
- Catalogue management costs. Mapping listings to the operator’s taxonomy, filling data gaps, moderation and translation. Unless automated, these costs grow in direct proportion to the number of listings.
- Payment and settlement costs. Payment splitting, seller payouts, KYC processing and multi-currency management.
- Dispute and return costs. Even when the seller is formally responsible, customers contact the operator.
- Compliance costs. The obligations described in the next section create ongoing work rather than a one-off task.
The practical implication is that marketplace profitability depends primarily on the extent to which catalogue management and settlements are automated. This is what separates a marketplace that scales to thousands of listings from one that stalls at two hundred because the team cannot keep up.
Legal obligations that fall on the operator
This is the aspect most often overlooked in content about marketplaces, yet it is also the one that most frequently delays implementations. By launching a marketplace, a business becomes a platform operator and is subject to a regulatory framework that did not apply to it in the same way as an online store.
Three of these obligations have direct architectural implications and are better addressed during the design stage than added later: seller data verification and storage under DAC7, trader traceability under the DSA, and VAT settlement rules within the payment engine.
What needs to be built: seven functional areas
A marketplace is more than an online store with an add-on. It consists of seven distinct areas, each of which can prevent the platform from going live.
- Seller onboarding. Registration, KYC verification, contracts and commission configuration. Onboarding time is a key metric: on mature platforms, KYC verification is completed in minutes rather than days. The data collected at this stage is the same data required for DAC7 reporting, so it is worth designing a single data collection process.
- Catalogue ingestion and normalisation. Imports via API, CSV, XML or EDI, mapping to the operator’s taxonomy, validation, filling data gaps and translation. This is where the scalability of the entire model is determined.
- Listing management and price competition. Multiple offers for the same product, logic for selecting the default offer, and transparent ranking rules as required by P2B.
- Orders and routing. Splitting a shopping basket across multiple sellers, separate shipments and consistent order status communication with the customer.
- Payments, commissions and payouts. Payment splitting, a commission engine with rules by seller and category, payout schedules, multi-currency support, and the handling of adjustments and refunds.
- Quality and moderation. Seller scoring, automated alerts, suspension of listings and accounts, and pre-publication content moderation.
- Seller portal. Self-service is a prerequisite for profitability. Every task a seller has to ask the operator to perform by email adds to the operator’s costs.
Choosing the right technology
There are three viable approaches. The choice depends mainly on the target number of sellers and the extent to which the commission model deviates from standard practices.
Mirakl is a reference point in this category, and its scale is worth understanding. According to the vendor’s own figures for 2025, it served more than 450 enterprise clients, and its operators generated over USD 14.6 billion in gross merchandise value (GMV), up 31% year on year. The platform supports both marketplace and dropshipping models within a single instance, while the Mirakl Connect network provides access to more than 100,000 brands and sellers, directly addressing the empty-shelf problem at launch.
The third approach is more common than platform vendors’ materials suggest. Models in which the subject of a transaction is not a conventional product, such as vehicle leasing or a medical service, cannot be accommodated by off-the-shelf platforms without significant compromises.
Five common mistakes
- Launching without sufficient supply. Going live with only a dozen or so listings. A customer who is disappointed twice will not return, and the cost of lost trust cannot be recovered through a marketing campaign.
- Failing to automate catalogue management. Manual mapping of listings works up to around two hundred products. Beyond that, the team becomes a bottleneck and growth stalls.
- Addressing settlements too late. Payment splitting, adjustments, refunds and payouts are more complex than the storefront, yet they are often left until the end of the project.
- Cannibalising your own assortment without making a deliberate decision. Without rules protecting categories with high own-product margins, profitability declines even as GMV grows.
- Treating compliance as a post-implementation task. DAC7, DSA and P2B requirements affect the data model and interface. Adding them later is more expensive than incorporating them into the initial design.
Implementation timeline and effort
The following estimates are based on our implementations of moderately complex marketplace projects.
A full launch typically takes between 8 and 14 months. The most common cause of delays is not technology but a lack of operational readiness on the operator’s side: an unstaffed seller support team and unresolved decisions about commission rules.
Strix’s experience
Strix is an e-commerce agency operating since 2009, with offices in Kraków, Utrecht and Frankfurt am Main, and a Mirakl partner. We have delivered marketplaces using both the conventional model and models that do not fit within off-the-shelf platforms.
- PKO Leasing: a comprehensive automotive marketplace in which the subject of the transaction is a financial product associated with a vehicle rather than a product held in stock.
- Medistore for Medicover: a marketplace for medical services, where supply consists of services with limited appointment availability.
- home&you: the transformation of an existing online store into a marketplace, an approach considered by most businesses with an established brand and existing traffic.
- Financial sector: a marketplace proof of concept developed ahead of the client’s investment decision.
- Decathlon: consultancy on the B2B shopping experience.
If our discussions show that dropshipping is the right next step for your business rather than a marketplace, we will say so. It is the recommendation we make most often in this area.
Frequently asked questions
How does a marketplace differ from an online store? In an online store, the operator is the seller vis-à-vis the customer, purchases inventory and earns a retail margin. In a marketplace, a third party is the seller, sets the price and bears inventory risk, while the operator earns a commission on transactions and manages traffic, data quality and trust.
When does building your own marketplace pay off? When you have traffic that you are not monetising, expanding your assortment through direct purchasing is unprofitable, and customers trust your platform enough to buy products from other brands. Without traffic, a marketplace has nothing to monetise.
What commissions do marketplace operators charge? In the enterprise market, commissions typically range from 8% to 15% of the transaction value, with operator EBITDA margins of around 7% to 9%. The rate depends on the category, the competitiveness of supply and the range of services offered to sellers.
How long does a marketplace implementation take? A full launch typically takes 8–14 months for a moderately complex project. The core functionality alone takes 4–7 months, with the remaining work covering the business model, payments, compliance and seller onboarding.
What legal obligations does a marketplace operator have in the European Union? Transparency towards sellers under the P2B Regulation (EU) 2019/1150, online platform obligations under the Digital Services Act (EU) 2022/2065, seller reporting under DAC7 (Council Directive (EU) 2021/514, applicable from 1 January 2023, with reporting due by 31 January), the VAT deemed supplier rules, and verification obligations under the GPSR.
Do I need Mirakl to launch a marketplace? No. Mirakl is an appropriate choice when the target is dozens or hundreds of sellers and a standard commission model. With a dozen or so sellers, extending an existing platform is usually sufficient. Where the subject of the transaction is non-standard, a custom-built solution may be necessary.
How can I solve the empty-shelf problem at launch? Three measures work in practice: onboarding a group of sellers before launch, using an existing seller network if your platform provides one, and launching in a single, narrow category where you can achieve real assortment depth rather than offering a broad but shallow catalogue.
Does a marketplace cannibalise first-party sales? Yes, if you do not establish rules. Decisions are needed on reserved categories, default offer selection logic, and commission rates that protect your own retail margins. Without these rules, GMV grows while profitability declines.
Is dropshipping a better first step than a marketplace? For many businesses, yes. Dropshipping expands the assortment without holding inventory, retains full control over pricing and the brand, and avoids triggering most platform operator obligations. It can be the right stage before launching a marketplace and, in some cases, the long-term operating model.
Next steps
The decision to launch a marketplace should start with unit economics and an assessment of your existing traffic, not platform selection. If you want to carry out this analysis using your own data, an operating model workshop is the starting point.
Strix, an e-commerce agency operating since 2009. Mirakl partner. Offices in Kraków, Utrecht and Frankfurt am Main.